Key Takeaways from the 28th Annual GIPS® Conference

The CFA Institute hosted its 28th Annual Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) Conference on September 17-18 in San Diego, CA. As always, the opportunity to reconnect with industry peers and colleagues was a highlight. We are grateful to all the speakers and panelists who shared their insights. Here are some key takeaways we found valuable from this year’s event.
The SEC Marketing Rule
The SEC Marketing Rule continues to be a topic of discussion, especially as we continue navigating the nuances of the rule and its implications for investment performance advertising. During the panel discussion, two presenters clarified several points:
Model vs. Actual Fees
It seems that there is rarely a case when the use of actual fees will adequately satisfy the marketing rule. This is a major development as at least 30% of the participants in the audience claim to still be using actual fees in their marketing.
According to the SEC marketing rule, when calculating net returns you can use actual or model fees. However, to satisfy the general prohibitions, an advisor generally should apply a model fee that reflects either the highest fee that was charged historically or the highest potential fee that it will charge the prospect receiving the advertisement (not a reasonable fee or an average). Footnotes 590 and 593 further clarify that there may be cases when using actual fees would specifically violate the marketing rule.
Footnote 590: “If the fee to be charged to the intended audience is anticipated to be higher than the actual fees charged, the adviser must use a model fee that reflects the anticipated fee to be charged in order not to violate the rule’s general prohibitions.”
and
Footnote 593: “…net performance that reflects a model fee that is not available to the intended audience is not permitted under the final rule’s second model fee provision.”
As a result, we recommend that anyone using actual fees in advertisements compare their net returns to the net returns that would have been achieved using the highest fee a prospect would pay as the model fee. If your actual net returns result in materially better performance than what the performance would be using the highest model fee, this is likely problematic. The rules do not define materiality, but the panelists did provide an example where the difference was only 25bp and they indicated that would likely be considered material.
If you do not have tools for calculating model fees, don’t worry, we are here to help. Reach out to one of our performance experts if you need help calculating model fees - we have tools that can simplify this for you.
Showing Multiple Net Returns in a Single Advertisement
Standardized marketing materials that show multiple net return results (including net of actual fees) may be presented in a single advertisement. This seems like a change of tone from what we heard last year, but this greatly simplifies what we thought previously. Since the adoption of the marketing rule, firms have struggled with how to standardize marketing materials, especially when they have different fee schedules and investor types.
Many firms now manage several versions of the same marketing document that show only the gross-of-fee returns and net-of-fee returns relevant to the specific audience receiving the advertisement. This can be logistically challenging to manage. Based on the discussion and case studies provided, it seems that firms are permitted to create a single document that shows various net-of-fee returns based on the fees charged to different investor types. The example provided looked something like this:

This shift in approach may be a huge relief for firms that are managing multiple investor types and are trying to track and update performance under various fee schedules. If electing to do this, it is important to ensure the fee proposed for the prospective investor is clear – especially when presenting a table like this to a retail investor. It is essential that your prospects can easily identify the net-of-fee return stream that is applicable for them.
Attribution & Contribution – Which is Performance?
Attribution is not considered performance while contribution likely is. Because Attribution is not considered performance, the use of a representative account is generally accepted. However, careful consideration should be applied in selecting an appropriate rep account and documentation to support its selection should be maintained. While the performance-related requirements of the Marketing Rule may not apply, the overarching requirement for the advertisement to be “fair and balanced” applies and must be considered when determining what account to use to represent the strategy.
A separate case study discussed how to handle situations when the rep account closes. Using the old rep account historically and linking its data to a new rep account is considered hypothetical, so if your rep account ceases to exist, it’s best to re-evaluate and select a different rep account to be used for the entire track record of the strategy.
Presenting Sector Contribution Returns Net-of-Fees
When presenting extracted performance, such as contribution or returns at the sector-level, this is treated as performance and must be presented net-of-fees. Since some firms have been mistakenly reducing each sector by a prorated portion of the percentage fee when determining the net-of-fee results, the panelists emphasized that when netting down sector returns, firms must deduct the full percentage fee from each sector. If allocating the dollar amount of the fee, that would be prorated by weighting the dollar amount of the fee by the weight the sector represents in the portfolio, but prorating a percentage will not create the same result and will overstate the sector-level net-of-fee returns.
The following example was provided to demonstrate how to apply model fees to sector returns and contribution in an advertisement:

Private Fund Gross & Net Returns
The calculation of gross and net returns for private funds must be consistent. For example, you cannot report a gross-of-fee return that excludes the impact of a subscription line of credit while reporting a net-of-fee return that includes it. Firms must disclose the effect of leverage, specifying the impact of subscription lines of credit rather than just stating that returns will be lower.
Per the marketing rule: gross- and net-of-fee returns must be calculated over the same time period, using the same type of return methodology. For example, it is not appropriate to calculate gross IRR using investment-level cash flows and net IRR using fund-level cash flows as that would be considered different methodologies.
Hypothetical Performance
Firms should be prepared to defend the classification of hypothetical or extracted performance. Hypothetical performance is defined as “performance that no specific account received.” Panelists made a point of noting that the return stream of a composite is not considered hypothetical, even though no specific account received the performance.
Along similar lines, a case study was presented where a firm wanted to show recommended funds to an existing client in a marketing presentation. The question was whether presenting a recommendation like this is considered hypothetical. Not surprisingly, the answer was “it depends on how the information was presented.” Presenting the information in a way that implied what the investor “could have received” would likely be hypothetical. Simply showing how these funds performed historically (so long as it complies with the marketing rule – showing prescribed time periods etc.) appeared acceptable.
AI in Investment Performance Reporting
The integration of AI into performance measurement and reporting continues to gain momentum. Of particular interest was how quickly our jobs may be changing and whether we need to be concerned about job security.
Jobs that focus on data gathering, prepping and cleaning are expected to be replaced by AI in the near future. We’ll likely see fewer new job postings for these entry-level roles, with a shift towards more value-added positions, such as data scientists, becoming more prevalent. Panelists suggested that many roles within the performance measurement function, including auditing, will likely be augmented, automating repetitive tasks (often performed by more junior professionals) and enhancing data analysis functions. Higher-level human oversight will still be essential for exercising judgment and interpreting information within the context of real-world scenarios – at least for now.
Panelists recommended preparing performance teams by encouraging them to take basic courses in Python and SQL to help prepare and empower them for the shift to a future with AI. AI platforms already exist that can perform detailed performance attribution and risk assessments by simply asking a question – much like one would with ChatGPT. It is likely that performance measurement professionals will continue to be needed to develop these platforms, and they will likely remain reliant on some human oversight for the foreseeable future.
Updates on the GIPS Standards
There were not a lot of updates on the GIPS Standards at the conference. As of July 31, 2024, 1,785 organizations across 51 markets claim compliance with the GIPS standards. This includes 85 of the top 100 global firms, and all 25 of the top 25 firms. The top five markets include the US, UK, Canada, Switzerland, and Japan, with Brazil emerging as a new market entrant in 2024.
The conference also provided updates on recent changes to the GIPS Standards. Key updates included:
- The Guidance Statement for OCIO Strategies will be released by year-end, providing more clarity for firms managing OCIO portfolios. It appears that gross-of-fee and net-of-fee returns will need to be presented for OCIO composites.
- The Guidance Statement for Firms Managing Only Broadly Distributed Pooled Funds(BDPFs) became effective on July 1, 2024. The new guidance offers increased flexibility for firms managing BDPFs, allowing them to avoid preparing GIPS Reports for prospective investors and instead focus on reporting for consultant databases or RFPs. While input data and return calculation requirements generally still apply, composite construction and report distribution are only required if the firm chooses to prepare GIPS Reports.
- The GIPS Technical Committee is forming a working group to address after-tax reporting. For now, firms should refer to the USIPC After-Tax Performance Standards, which were issued in 2011. Additionally, as there is little consensus on how to calculate private fund returns, the committee plans to provide further guidance—though a timeline was not specified.
These takeaways underscore the evolving nature of the investment performance landscape. If you have any questions, please don’t hesitate to reach out to us. We would be happy to share additional insights from the conference as well as jump start your firm in complying with the GIPS Standards.
GIPS® is a registered trademark owned by CFA Institute. CFA Institute does not endorse or promote this organization, nor does it warrant the accuracy or quality of the content contained herein.
Popular Post
CFA Institute hosted the 30th Annual Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) Conference on November 10 and 11, 2026 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Thirty years in, the conference still does what it does best, bringing the performance community together to work through the issues that land on our desks. It was good to reconnect with familiar faces and to see plenty of first timers in the room.
The theme was shaping what is next in investment performance, and one topic ran through nearly every session: artificial intelligence. AI was not limited to the sessions dedicated to it. It came up in verification, in the SEC discussion, in the GIPS Standards update, and across the questions attendees submitted all week. Other themes included SEC examination priorities, proposed guidance on trade errors, performance-based fee calculations, the retailization of private markets, and the asset owner view of GIPS compliance. Here are the takeaways worth passing along.
AI Took Center Stage
The audience polls reflected both enthusiasm for AI and caution about its use. Seventy-five percent of attendees expect AI and automation to have the greatest impact on verification over the next five years. At the same time, 84% were least comfortable fully delegating final approval of client communications to AI. Roughly 80% also believe the GIPS standards need little adjustment in response to AI, with only minor tweaks necessary.
CFA Institute's framing seemed reassuring for firms already experimenting. AI is treated as one more tool in the performance process, much like an accounting or performance system. Using it does not, by itself, jeopardize a firm's GIPS compliance. What matters is how firms oversee its use. CFA Institute is researching model bias and ethics to decide whether changes to the standards are needed.
The practical sessions showed how much is already possible, from building efficient frontier analysis and tracking error decomposition to drafting attribution commentary with an AI agent in a fraction of the usual time. The consistent message from presenters was that the human must be in the loop. One speaker summed it upwell: delegate tasks, but do not delegate responsibility. Some errors are harder to spot than an obvious hallucination. For example, where the numbers are right, but the interpretation is wrong. The expectation is a clear chain of evidence behind any result, with a qualified person reviewing it before it goes out.
That theme carried into record keeping. When AI contributes to a calculation, a disclosure, or a GIPS Report, firms should retain enough information to support and recreate the result, as verifiers or regulators may ask for it. In practice that means documenting how AI is used in your policies and procedures, keeping version control over prompts, and retaining the underlying data. The accountability does not transfer to the software.
CFA Institute is gathering industry input through its AI and performance survey. Responses will help inform any future updates to the GIPS standards. If you work in performance, we encourage you to participate. Keep an eye out for the survey from CFA Institute as it has currently only been made available on the conference app, but we hope they will send it out soon.
The GIPS Standards Update: What Is New and What Is Coming
As of October31, 2026, 1,647 organizations across 51 markets claim compliance with the GIPS standards, including 25 of the top 25 and 85 of the top 100 global firms. Adoption remains strongest in the US, UK, Canada, Switzerland, and South Africa, with Saudi Arabia now in the top ten.
The headline project is a proposed Guidance Statement on Trade Errors, out for comment through December 15, 2026. Trade errors happen at every firm, and the proposal addresses how to handle them in portfolios and composites alongside a firm's error correction policy. The key points in the proposed new guidance are that a trade error policy would be optional, much like a significant cash flow policy, while error correction stays mandatory for compliant firms. The guidance would add a narrow new reason a firm may remove a portfolio from a composite. Presenters were clear that this is not a way to drop a poor performer by calling it an error, and that firms would need consistent materiality thresholds. If you have opinions you would like to share about this guidance before it is finalized, please submit your comment letters to gipsstandards@cfainstitute.orgby 15 December.
CFA Institute also released a Guide for Return Attribution Reporting and the third edition of its paper Reconciling the GIPS Standards and the SEC Marketing Rule. Further out, a GIPS 2030consultation paper is taking shape, with net-of-fee presentation, model portfolios, after-tax reporting, and AI all on the list. One idea under consideration would let firms present the net return relevant to a prospect, not only the most conservative net return, which would help align the GIPS standards with the SEC Marketing Rule.
SEC Marketing Rule and the Current State of Exams
Mark Dowdell of the SEC Division of Examinations gave another candid session. The 2027 exam program is squarely retail focused, with attention on fiduciary duties, conflicts of interest, liquidity, complex products, and private credit valuation, along with cybersecurity and AI.
On the Marketing Rule, recent staff guidance has eased two pain points. Firms now have a safe harbor to show investment characteristics and extracted performance on a gross basis, as long as the related composite or total-portfolio gross and net returns appear with equal prominence over the same period and the gross figures are clearly labeled. Firms also have more flexibility to present net performance using actual fees even when those are lower than the anticipated fee, with appropriate disclosure. Also, it was clarified that returns that comply with the SEC Marketing Rule, but do not meet the requirements of the GIPS standards, may be presented as supplemental information for a GIPS compliant firm.
Examination findings continue to highlight familiar weaknesses. Firms are still cited for policies that were never updated for the Marketing Rule and for annual reviews that lack real testing. Hypothetical and predecessor performance remain trouble spots, and examiners continue to check incentive fee calculations against the governing documents. On AI, the message was straightforward: if you use it to help review or sign off on performance, have policies around it, human oversight, and supporting documentation, because the staff will ask how the tools are used. The SEC also cited firms that exaggerate their use of AI.
Performance-Based Fees: Small Details, Significant Implications
A session on performance-based fees drove home a single point: small differences in contractual language can materially change what a general partner earns. Compounding frequency, catch-up provisions, high-water marks, and the choice between European and American style waterfalls can each swing the result. Whether carried interest is structured as a fee or an allocation of profit can also change its tax implications.
The session emphasized the need for shared understanding of the calculation. Lawyers draft the terms, administrators calculate the fees, and auditors verify the result. The intent, the language, and the calculation all have to agree. Many attendees asked whether any system can handle bespoke fee calculations well or if the work still ends up in Excel. The vast majority still seem to be using Excel for these calculations although there is some shift to software solutions. A pending SEC proposal could extend the use of incentive fees to a broader set of public funds, potentially bringing these challenges to more of the industry.
Private Markets and Retailization
As private markets expand into wealth and retirement channels, the recurring message was that access is only part of the equation. As one panelist put it, private markets are a decision inside plan design, not a decision instead of it.
The harder issue is valuation. In semi-liquid and evergreen vehicles, the net asset value is not just a reporting mark, it is the price at which investors subscribe and redeem. This makes valuation accuracy more important than ever. Appraisal-based values can smooth volatility and delay the recognition of losses, and every private market metric ultimately rests on an estimate of what is still held. The guidance for practitioners was to clearly separate realized cash returns from the manager’s unrealized estimates, disclose smoothing and benchmark limits, and tailor the disclosure to the investor. It was also noted that even when AI supports a valuation model, the valuer remains accountable for the result.
Asset Owner Perspectives
A panel of GIPS compliant asset owners, including the Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia, MassPRIM, and the Pennsylvania Treasury, shared why they pursued compliance when no client required it. In each case the decision came from the top and was about institutional excellence and the confidence that independently verified numbers give boards, oversight bodies, and the external managers they hire. One panelist described compliance by osmosis: once the organization commits, the whole team pays closer attention to the inputs that drive performance, and issues get caught before they grow.
A poll showed that most asset owner RFPs now ask whether managers are GIPS compliant, and a growing number ask across all asset classes. This pulls compliance into less transparent parts of the market such as private assets. The panelists were candid about shared challenges, including lagged private market valuations, but were encouraging about the path forward for more asset owners to claim compliance. They noted that compliance is achievable even with a small team when the right custodian, verifier, and consultant are in place.
This is one of the threads we watched most closely. Asset owner adoption raises the bar for everyone, because an asset owner that has done the work expects the same discipline, ethics, and full disclosure from the managers it hires. Helping asset owners and the managers they evaluate meet that standard is a core part of our work, and we expect this community to keep driving demand for GIPS compliance across asset classes.
Final Thoughts
For all the focus on technology, the message from Philadelphia was that the fundamentals have not changed. AI can improve the speed and quality of performance work, but trustworthy reporting still depends on transparency, consistency, documentation, and human accountability. The firms that come out ahead will treat AI as leverage for their expertise rather than a replacement for it, and keep their policies, records, and review processes a step ahead of the tools.
At Longs Peak, we help firms and asset owners put these principles into practice. We helpbuild practical, well-controlled performance and GIPS compliant processes, from composite construction, performance reporting, and Marketing Rule presentations to preparation for verification. Increasingly, it also includes helping clientsdocument and oversee AI use within those processes. If you would like to talk through how any of these developments affect your organization, please contact us.
There is a common assumption among boutique investment managers that the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) are built for the largest firms in the industry — that compliance is something you pursue once you've reached a certain scale, a certain client type, or a certain level of institutional credibility.
That assumption is understandable. And it is costing firms real opportunities.
The GIPS standards have no AUM threshold to get started. There is no minimum number of clients or composites required before a firm can claim compliance. And increasingly, the institutional marketplace is not waiting for firms to reach some undefined moment of readiness before asking for it. If you are newer to the GIPS standards and want a foundation for what they are and why firms pursue them, start with our post What Are the GIPS Standards?
The Market Has Already Decided
The gatekeepers of institutional capital such as consultants, outsourced CIO platforms, model delivery networks, and institutional allocators, have been quietly raising the bar on performance reporting standards for years. GIPS compliance has shifted from a differentiator to a baseline expectation in many of these channels.
According to eVestment, two out of three manager searches conducted by investors and consultants on their platform exclude firms that are not GIPS compliant. That means boutique managers without a compliance claim are not being passed over, they are simply not being seen. As we explored in From Compliance to Growth, GIPS compliance has effectively become the price of admission for firms seeking to expand into institutional channels.
The question is not whether your firm will eventually need it. For most managers with institutional ambitions, the answer to that question is already yes. The real question is when you choose to pursue it, and whether you make that choice on your own terms or in response to a mandate you cannot afford to lose.
What Compliance Actually Builds Inside Your Firm
The benefits most managers focus on are external. Things like the credibility signal, the access to channels, the due diligence box that gets checked. Those benefits are real. But some of the most meaningful returns from GIPS compliance are internal.
Implementing the GIPS standards requires firms to formalize processes that often exist informally. Composite definitions. Discretion criteria. Benchmark selection rationale. Fee policies. Error correction procedures. For many boutique managers, the implementation process is the first time these decisions have been documented and applied consistently across the firm.
That discipline matters beyond GIPS compliance itself. A firm with clean, documented performance infrastructure is better positioned for regulatory examinations, investor due diligence, and operational due diligence reviews. It demonstrates to sophisticated allocators that the firm is run with the same rigor they apply to their own oversight responsibilities. And for firms that are not primarily focused on institutional distribution, this operational foundation has standalone value, the kind of infrastructure that supports sound governance regardless of who is asking. For more on what a well-governed GIPS compliance program looks like once it is in place, see What Good GIPS Compliance Governance Looks Like in Practice.
The Single Best Argument for Starting Now
Here is the point that does not get made often enough: the smaller your firm and the shorter your track record, the easier it is to become compliant. That ratio flips quickly as you grow.
Retroactively constructing composites across a large number of separate accounts is genuinely difficult work, particularly when no framework existed at the time to assign accounts to composites at inception, or to move accounts between composites as investment objectives changed, client restrictions were added or removed, or mandates evolved. Working through that history portfolio by portfolio, period by period, requires both detailed documentation and sound judgment. It is one of the most time-consuming phases of any GIPS compliance implementation, and the complexity compounds with every account and every year of history added.
A firm with 30 separate accounts and a two-year track record faces a very different implementation project than the same firm a few years later with 500 accounts and a five-year track record. The strategy, the clients, and the investment process may be nearly identical, but the administrative burden of reconstructing historical composite membership correctly is not.
The firms that find implementation most manageable are the ones that started before the project grew into something unwieldy. The firms that find it most painful are the ones that waited until an institutional prospect made it urgent.
What if you are not ready to commit to full compliance yet?
That is a legitimate position. But there is a practical middle path worth considering: even if a firm does not want to claim compliance with the GIPS standards today, building out the composite structure and creating policies and procedures for managing those composites now is a worthwhile investment. That framework does not require a formal compliance claim to be useful. Additionally, it can be carried directly into a full GIPS compliance program when the time is right, dramatically reducing the effort required at that stage.
The Real Costs
Becoming GIPS compliant requires real work, and it is worth being direct about what that entails. At a high level, implementation comes down to four phases: defining the firm, building a GIPS standards policies and procedures manual, constructing composites and calculating performance, and creating GIPS Reports with ongoing monitoring controls. We walk through each phase in detail in A Practical Framework for Implementing the GIPS Standards.
In terms of ongoing commitment, firms should expect monthly composite management, annual GIPS Report updates, periodic policies and procedures reviews, and distribution tracking. For a lean team, owning all of this internally is often not realistic. The good news is that outsourcing to a GIPS compliance consultant is a well-established path for boutique managers and one that many firms in our client base have taken successfully. The total cost of compliance for a focused, well-organized firm is frequently lower than managers expect, particularly when implementation is approached while the firm's history and account universe are still manageable.
Is This the Right Time for Your Firm?
Not every firm is at the same point in this decision. Managers with the strongest case for pursuing GIPS compliance now include:
- Firms actively pursuing institutional mandates or seeking coverage from investment consultants
- Managers on model delivery platforms or building toward that distribution channel
- Firms planning meaningful growth over the next two to three years
- Any manager whose clients or prospects have already raised the question
- Firms that simply want to build a best-in-class performance reporting foundation, regardless of where their distribution strategy stands today
The case is lower urgency for firms focused exclusively on high-net-worth or retail clients with no near-term institutional ambitions; however, there is still value in building a sound performance reporting structure, and the sooner it is established, the easier the work will be.
On Verification: You Can Wait
Verification is independent, voluntary, and valuable. It is also not required to claim compliance with the GIPS standards, and for cost-conscious boutiques, it is a reasonable place to exercise flexibility.
A firm can become GIPS compliant today and gain all the operational benefits and the ability to make the compliance claim and defer pursuing verification until there is specific demand for it. When an institutional prospect or consultant asks whether the firm is verified, that is the right moment to add it. The compliance foundation built now makes that future engagement faster and less disruptive. For a detailed walkthrough of what the verification process involves, see our series How to Survive a GIPS Verification.
Verification is worth having. It just does not need to happen on day one.
The Longer You Wait, The Heavier the Lift
GIPS compliance is not an initiative that gets easier with time. Every year a firm grows its account base, extends its track record, and adds complexity to its operations without a compliance framework in place is another year of history that will eventually need to be organized, documented, and reconstructed.
The managers who find implementation most straight forward are not the ones with the most resources. They are the ones who started early enough that the project was still proportionate to the size of the task.
If your firm is headed toward institutional distribution (most boutique managers we work with are), the best time to build this infrastructure is before you need it. The second best time is now.
Longs Peak Advisory Services specializes in GIPS compliance and investment performance consulting for investment managers and asset owners. We have helped over 250 firms implement and maintain compliance with the GIPS standards. If you are evaluating whether now is the right time for your firm, we would be glad to talk through it. Reach out athello@longspeakadvisory.com.
GIPS® is a registered trademark owned by CFA Institute. CFA Institute does not endorse or promote this organization, nor does it warrant the accuracy or quality of the content contained herein.
Most firms that decide to pursue compliance with the Performance Standards (GIPS®) already understand why it matters. They know institutional investors and consultants often expect it. They understand the credibility that comes from standardized, transparent performance reporting. And they recognize that a strong performance reporting process can improve internal consistency well beyond marketing.
What many firms struggle with is not the “why,” but the“how.”
The GIPS standards can be especially intimidating at first glance. There are detailed requirements, technical terminology, and a long list of considerations that touch everything from performance, to operations, compliance, and marketing. For firms approaching GIPS compliance for the first time, it is easy to feel like they need to solve everything at once.
Whether working independently or with external GIPS support,becoming GIPS compliant is significantly more manageable when approachedthrough a structured process.
At a high level, implementing the GIPS standards comes down to four major phases:
- Define the firm and scope the universe of portfolios
- Build policies and procedures
- Construct composites and calculate performance
- Create GIPS Reports and establish ongoing monitoring controls
The order matters more than many firms realize. When the foundation is built correctly at the beginning, the downstream work becomes significantly easier. For a broader overview of what the GIPS standards are and why firms choose to comply, see our earlier post, What Are the GIPS Standards?
Phase 1: Define the Firm and Scope Your Universe
Before constructing composites or calculating returns, firms first need to define the “firm” for the purpose of claiming compliance with the GIPS standards. This sounds simple, but it is often one of the most important decisions in the entire implementation process.
The GIPS standards require compliance on a firm-wide basis. Firms cannot selectively apply compliance to only their best-performing strategies or business lines. The firm definition determines which portfolios fall within the scope of compliance and ultimately impacts composite construction, total firm assets, disclosures, and marketing claims.
For smaller organizations, this step is often straightforward. The legal entity, branding, regulatory registration, and operational structure are usually aligned. In those situations, the firm definition may be relatively easy to document.
For larger organizations with complex legal structures or ones that operate under multiple brands, the analysis can become significantly more complex.
The following questions should be considered:
- How is the firm held out to the public?
- Do affiliates or subsidiaries share investment personnel or investment decision-making?
- How are the various entities registered and branded relative to one another?
- How are investment strategies actually managed across entities?
The answer to these questions matters because the firm definition affects everything that follows. For complex organizations, it is worth investing real time here and involving compliance and legal teams before any other work begins.
Once the firm is defined, the next step is performing a full inventory of assets (or portfolios) that fall within the defined firm. That includes discretionary accounts, non-discretionary accounts, pooled funds, terminated portfolios, and any other assets managed by the firm over the entire period for which the firm will claim compliance.
One of the most common implementation mistakes is discovering late in the process that certain portfolios were overlooked or incorrectly categorized. Taking the time upfront to fully scope the universe of portfolios prevents significant cleanup work later on.
Phase 2: Build Your GIPS Standards Policies & Procedures Manual
The next step is building the firm’s GIPS standards policies and procedures manual, often referred to as the GIPS standards “P&P.”
The GIPS standards require firms to document the policies and procedures used to comply with all applicable requirements. But beyond satisfying the standards themselves, strong documentation creates consistency across operations, compliance, marketing, and portfolio management teams. Your GIPS standards P&P becomes the operational blueprint for how your firm calculates performance and maintains GIPS compliance. When drafted thoughtfully, ongoing maintenance becomes manageable. Firms that rush this phase often find themselves cleaning up problems indefinitely.
A well-designed P&P typically addresses the following:
- Firm definition
- Definition of discretion
- Composite construction rules
- Treatment of significant cash flows and composite minimums
- Calculation methodologies
- Fair valuation hierarchy
- Error correction procedures
- Books and records retention
- GIPS Report distribution policies
- Benchmark selection and changes
- Fee schedules and policies for the use of actual or model fees
The definition of discretion deserves particular attention. Under the GIPS standards, discretion is not the same thing as having legal discretion documented in the investment management agreement. A client may impose restrictions that prevent full implementation of the strategy, and if those restrictions are significant enough, the portfolio should be classified as non-discretionary under the GIPS standards. Firms should establish objective criteria that can be applied consistently across portfolios and clearly document those criteria within their P&P. This determination has a direct impact on composite construction, as only portfolios deemed discretionary maybe included in composites, while non-discretionary portfolios must be excluded.
Calculation methodology should also be clearly addressed within the P&P. Firms should define how external cash flows are handled, the methodology used to asset-weight portfolios within composites, and whether any composites are subject to minimum asset levels or significant cash flow policies. For a more detailed discussion of large cash flow policies versus significant cash flow policies—and why both matter—see our post Large vs. Significant Cash Flows: What’s the Difference? These methodologies should be clearly documented.
Finally, firms often do not devote enough attention to developing their error correction policy during implementation. The GIPS standards require firms to establish materiality thresholds in advance that determine what actions must be taken when an error is identified. The time to think through that process is before an error occurs, not in the middle of responding to one.
We often find that this is the phase where firms realize that implementing GIPS compliance is not just a performance reporting exercise. It frequently exposes inconsistencies in operational workflows, account coding, historical records, or portfolio classifications. That is not necessarily a bad thing. It allows you to intentionally strengthen processes and reporting before those issues surface in higher-stakes situations such as verification, a regulatory examination, or investor due diligence.
One of the biggest hidden benefits of the GIPS compliance implementation process is that it forces firms to formalize processes that may have evolved informally over time. Many firms come out of the GIPS compliance implementation process with cleaner data, stronger internal controls, and more consistency across teams.
The key is to make the policies practical. The best GIPS standards P&Ps are not written purely for regulators or verifiers. They are designed to reflect what the firm actually does in practice and to provide internal teams with a framework they can follow consistently.
Phase 3: Construct Composites and Calculate Performance
Once your policies and procedures are in place, firms can begin the process of constructing composites and calculating performance. This is the phase most firms typically associate with GIPS compliance because it is where the visible performance reporting work happens. At this point, much of the difficult decision-making should already be complete. Composite construction is next and while that may sound straightforward conceptually, this is the phase where most firms get stuck in the implementation process.
Under the GIPS standards, discretionary portfolios must be grouped into composites based on similar investment mandates. The goal is to ensure firms present strategy-level performance fairly and consistently instead of selectively highlighting individual account results. The construction process typically has four steps:
- Identify every portfolio that meets the composite definition
- Determine the correct dates each portfolio should be in and out of the composite
- Asset-weight the portfolio-level monthly returns to produce composite-level performance
- Calculate all required composite-level statistics, including internal dispersion and the three-year annualized ex-post standard deviation of both the composite and the benchmark
It sounds simple, but it’s not always easy. The data work alone is substantial. Before anything meaningful can be built, the underlying portfolio-level data must be reviewed to ensure it is reconciled and accurate. That foundation matters because everything downstream depends on it.
The historical composite membership analysis adds another layer of complexity. Strategies evolve. Clients add or remove restrictions. Portfolios change mandates. When building a composite with a ten-year history, the question is not simply which portfolios belong in the composite today. Itis which portfolios belonged in the composite during each period in the historical record, and why. Working through that analysis portfolio by portfolio and period by period requires both strong documentation and sound judgment.
The good news is that there are tools available to help firms identify historical performance outliers to help test if composite inclusion was accurate. When a portfolio within a composite posts a return that deviates meaningfully from its peers during a given period, that deviation can be identified for further research. Was there a client-imposed restriction during that period that prevented full implementation of the strategy (i.e., making it non-discretionary)? Or was the deviation driven by a large cash flow, different starting position, security-specific activity, or simply the normal variation expected across portfolios managed within the same strategy? The answer determines whether the portfolio appropriately belongs in the composite for that period, and the wrong conclusion in either direction can undermine the integrity of the track record.
It is also important to be direct about the limits of technology in this process. Software can identify anomalies, efficiently perform calculations, and output results once the inputs are correct, but no system makes judgment calls. Determining how composites should be defined, how discretion should be applied, what constitutes a significant restriction, and how to evaluate edge cases in historical membership all require experienced professionals who understand both the investment strategies and the GIPS standards. The policies documented in Phase 2 provide the framework but applying that framework consistently across real portfolios and real historical circumstances requires thoughtful human judgment at every step.
Perhaps most importantly, composite construction should not be treated purely as an operations exercise. If composites are built solely around how data happens to be structured within the portfolio accounting system, without input from the investment team and without alignment with sales and marketing, the result may be operationally convenient but commercially ineffective. Bringing together operations, performance, investment professionals, and sales and marketing teams early in the process is essential. That collaboration is what ultimately produces results that are not only GIPS compliant, but also meaningful, defensible, and aligned with how the firm communicates its investment approach.
Phase 4: Create GIPS Reports and Go Live
The final phase of becoming compliant is creating the GIPS Composite Report(s). The GIPS Report is the firm’s external-facing proof of compliance and is a presentation that must be provided to every prospective client. Getting to this stage is what most people think of as going live, but in practice it is a milestone, not the finish line.
GIPS Reports require more than simply presenting returns in a table. Firms must include required statistics, disclosures, benchmark information, and firm-level details necessary for prospective clients to properly interpret the results. The disclosures are especially important because they provide context investors need to understand how the performance was calculated and what the results represent. They are very specific and must be in sync with what is documented in the P&P and what was performed to construct the composites. For more specifics on what is required, see our previous post, How to Update Your GIPS Reports for the 2020 GIPS Standards.
Once the GIPS Reports are complete and all requirements have been met, the final administrative step to claiming compliance is submitting the GIPS Compliance Notification Form to CFA Institute. This must be filed before compliance can be claimed, and it must be renewed annually.
Ongoing Maintenance: Where Most Firms Struggle
Getting to compliance is an achievement. Staying there requires consistent operational discipline.
The most common breakdowns in ongoing maintenance are rarely dramatic failures. More often, they are small process gaps that compound over time. Portfolios that should have been added to composites were omitted or added late. Significant cash flows were not handled in accordance with the composite’s policy. A new strategy was launched without formally determining whether it warranted the creation of a new composite.
To avoid these breakdowns, firms should incorporate GIPS compliance procedures into their regular monthly or quarterly performance processes rather than treating compliance as an annual reporting exercise. Clear ownership should be assigned internally and firms should establish a recurring compliance calendar that includes monthly composite reviews and annual GIPS Report updates. The GIPS standards policy manual should also be reviewed at least annually to confirm it continues to reflect how the firm actually operates. For a deeper look at what effective ongoing governance looks like in practice, see our post What Good GIPS Compliance Governance Looks Like in Practice.
Should You Get Verified
Verification is not required. Firms that are early in the process sometimes view this as a bigger decision than it needs to be. If a firm chooses to pursue verification, it must be performed by an independent third party, but the decision itself is entirely voluntary.
That said, verification is generally worthwhile, particularly for firms competing for institutional mandates where GIPS compliance is often considered table stakes. According to eVestment, two out of three searches conducted in their database by investors or consultants exclude firms that are not GIPS compliant, so the marketing benefit can be meaningful. Verification also provides an added level of assurance that the firm’s policies and procedures have been designed in accordance with the GIPS standards and implemented consistently across the organization. Operationally, it can create valuable discipline as well, since the expectation of independent review encourages firms to maintain strong processes throughout the year.
For firms that are newer to compliance or navigating budget constraints, the best path is often to first establish a solid compliance foundation and then pursue verification when the timing makes sense. We have also worked alongside nearly every major verifier in the industry and can provide practical insight into how different firms approach the process, what working styles may align best with your organization, and how to evaluate which verifier may be the best fit for your needs. For a more detailed walkthrough of the process, see our series on How to Survive a GIPS Verification.
Final Thoughts
Becoming GIPS compliant can feel overwhelming at the start, especially when going through it for the first time. But it does not have to be. For firms that approach implementation as a structured operational framework — rather than a collection of isolated technical requirements —typically find the process much more manageable.
The goal is not simply to produce a compliant presentation. The real value comes from building a repeatable, transparent, and defensible framework for calculating and presenting investment performance.
When implemented thoughtfully, the GIPS standards do more than support marketing efforts. They help firms improve consistency, strengthen controls, and communicate performance results with greater credibility and transparency. And in an environment where investors continue to demand greater transparency and comparability, those operational improvements can provide a meaningful competitive advantage, strengthening both credibility and investor confidence.
If you’ve been around the Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) long enough, you know that governance is one of those topics everyone agrees is important, but far fewer firms can clearly explain what good governance with the GIPS standards actually looks like day to day.
Most firms don’t fail at GIPS compliance because they misunderstand a technical requirement. They struggle because ownership is unclear, decisions are informal, or key knowledge lives in one person’s head. When that person leaves (or when the firm grows) things start to break.
So, let’s simplify this.
Below is a practical, real-world view of what good governance looks like when complying with the GIPS standards—not in theory, not in a policy document that no one reads, but in how well-run firms actually operate.
Start with the Right Mindset: Governance Is About Sustainability
At its core, GIPS compliance exists to answer one question:
Can this firm consistently calculate, maintain, and present performance fairly and accurately—regardless of growth, staff changes, or market stress?
The GIPS standards are built on the principles of fair representation and full disclosure, but governance is what turns those principles into repeatable behavior. Good governance doesn’t mean more paperwork or compliance headaches. It means clear accountability, documented decisions, and controls that actually get used.
1. Clear Ownership (It’s Rarely Just One Person)
One of the most common governance risks we see is a “GIPS compliance department of one” where critical knowledge, decisions, and processes are concentrated with a single individual. While this can work in the short term, it creates challenges around continuity, oversight, and scalability as the firm grows or changes.
Good governance starts by clearly defining:
- Who owns GIPS compliance overall
- Who performs monthly/quarterly/annual tasks
- Who reviews and approves key inputs/outputs
- Who resolves judgment calls
- Who ensures it also complies with other relevant regulations
In practice, this often looks like:
- A GIPS compliance committee or designated governance group
- Representation from performance, compliance, operations, and senior management
- Defined escalation paths for gray areas (e.g., discretion, composite changes, error corrections)
When a firm isn’t large enough to support a formal committee, outsourcing to a GIPS compliance consultant or a provider of managed services can be an effective alternative. These individuals can help you design policies, create procedures, and essentially manage governance for you.
But even if you are big enough, having an independent third party on your GIPS compliance committee can provide an objective, well-informed perspective formed by experience across many firms and a deep understanding of what works well in practice.
2. Policies and Procedures That Reflect Reality
Every GIPS compliant firm has GIPS standards policies and procedures (GIPS standards P&P). Well-governed firms actually use them.
Strong GIPS compliance governance means your GIPS standards P&P:
- Include procedures your firm actually follows instead of only stating policies
- Reflect how performance is really calculated
- Clearly document firm-specific elections and judgments
- Are updated when the business changes (for new products, systems, asset classes)
Think of your GIPS standards P&P as the firm’s operating manual for performance, not a static compliance artifact. If someone new joined your performance team tomorrow, they should be able to follow your policies and procedures to calculate performance and arrive at the same results. If not, governance needs work.
3. Formalized Review and Oversight
Good governance includes independent review, even if it’s internal.
In practice, this often means:
- Secondary review of composite membership decisions
- Review of significant cash flow thresholds and discretion determinations
- Approval of new composites and composite definition changes
- Oversight of error identification and correction
This is where governance protects firms from subtle but costly mistakes, especially those that show up during verification and increase complexity and scope of these engagements. In an ideal situation, these internal reviews should catch issues before they become problems.
As a provider of managed services, Longs Peak helps firms identify performance outliers, accounts that are breaking composite rules, and other data anomalies. This review significantly reduces the risk of erroneous data ending up in your performance and later caught in verification. If you are not able to do this internally, we strongly recommend outsourcing this effort.
4. Governance Extends to Marketing and Distribution
One area that has been increasingly important is the intersection of GIPS compliance, the SEC marketing rule, and how you manage the distribution of marketing materials.
Well-governed firms:
- Control who can distribute GIPS Reports and how they are distributed
- Ensure Marketing understands what is and is not an advertisement that meets the requirements of the GIPS standards
- Coordinate GIPS compliance requirements with broader regulatory rules, including the SEC marketing rule
- Have a clear process for tracking distribution
This alignment helps firms avoid inconsistencies between factsheets, pitchbooks, and GIPS Reports—one of the fastest ways to lose credibility with prospects and regulators.
Some clients prefer not to mention GIPS compliance at all in their marketing (i.e., on their factsheets and pitchbooks) until a client is clearly interested in one of their strategies. Once they meet the definition of a prospect (as outlined in your GIPS standards P&P), it triggers the requirement to send a GIPS Report and they find this smaller list of prospects easier to maintain. For others, having everything in one document including required GIPS compliance information and disclosures is easier to manage than separate documents.
There is no “right” way to manage this, but in either case, having a clear process for tracking and reporting performance errors is key.
5. Documentation of Decisions (Not Just Results)
Here’s a subtle but critical point: Good governance for your GIPS compliance program documents decisions, not just outcomes.
Why was that composite redefined?
Why was this benchmark changed?
Why was this model fee selected?
Strong governance creates an audit trail that:
- Supports sound reasoning (which aides in the verification process or even regulatory exams later on)
- Reduces key person risk
- Makes future reviews faster and less stressful
This is especially valuable when firms grow, merge, or experience turnover. Clear documentation allows others to step in seamlessly and continue critical functions without disruption. More importantly, it enables independent parties, such as a regulator or your verifier, to understand, assess, and validate how you are calculating and presenting performance that may not be immediately intuitive.
6. Governance Is Ongoing, Not a One-Time Project
The best-governed firms don’t “set and forget” their GIPS compliance program. They revisit governance when:
- New strategies launch
- Systems or custodians change
- Regulations evolve
- The firm’s structure changes
In other words, governance evolves with the business—because performance reporting doesn’t exist in a vacuum.
Even for firms that are not regularly launching new strategies, changing systems or structure, an annual review of your GIPS compliance program and governance framework is critical. This review helps confirm that practices have remained consistent, while also providing an opportunity to reflect on whether you are satisfied with your verifier, assess whether new regulations require updates, and reconsider how composites are managed or described.
The best time to do this is at year-end so that if you decide something should be changed, you can do that proactively for the upcoming year, rather than having to fix it retroactively.
What Good GIPS Compliance Governance Really Buys You
When GIPS compliance governance is working well, firms experience:
- A structured, intentional process for validation of your performance results
- A framework that supports consistency and transparency over time
- Fewer surprises or last-minute scrambles during verification or regulatory review
- Greater confidence from regulators and verifiers that you are following established policies and procedures
- Lower operational and reputational risk
Most importantly, it creates trust internally and externally. Good GIPS compliance governance isn’t about being perfect. It’s about being intentional.
Clear ownership. Thoughtful documentation. Real oversight. Those are the firms that don’t just claim compliance, they live it.
Key Takeaways from the 29th Annual GIPS® Standards Conference in Phoenix
The 29th Annual Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) Conference was held November 11–12, 2025, at the Sheraton Grand at Wild Horse Pass in Phoenix, Arizona—a beautiful desert resort and an ideal setting for two days of discussions on performance reporting, regulatory expectations, and practical implementation challenges. With no updates released to the GIPS standards this year, much of the content focused on application, interpretation, and the broader reporting and regulatory environment that surrounds the standards.
One of the few topics directly tied to GIPS compliance with a near-term impact relates to OCIO portfolios. Beginning with performance presentations that include periods through December 31, 2025, GIPS compliant firms with OCIO composites must present performance following a newly prescribed, standardized format. We published a high-level overview of these requirements previously.
The conference also covered related topics such as the SEC Marketing Rule, private fund reporting expectations, SEC exam trends, ethical challenges, and methodology consistency. Below are the themes and observations most relevant for firms today.
Are Changes Coming to the GIPS Standards in 2030?
Speakers emphasized that while no new GIPS standards updates were introduced this year, expectations for consistent, well-documented implementation continue to rise. Many attendee questions highlighted that challenges often stem more from inconsistent application or interpretation than from unclear requirements.
Several audience members also asked whether a “GIPS 2030” rewrite might be coming, similar to the major updates in 2010 and 2020. The CFA Institute and GIPS Technical Committee noted that:
· No new version of the standards is currently in development,
· A long-term review cycle is expected in the coming years, and
· A future update is possible later this decade as the committee evaluates whether changes are warranted.
For now, the standards remain stable—giving firms a window to refine methodologies, tighten policies, and align practices across teams.
Performance Methodology Under the SEC Marketing Rule
The Marketing Rule featured prominently again this year, and presenters emphasized a familiar theme: firms must apply performance methodologies consistently when private fund results appear in advertising materials.
Importantly, these expectations do not come from prescriptive formulas within the rule. They stem from:
1. The “fair and balanced” requirement,
2. The Adopting Release, and
3. SEC exam findings that view inconsistent methodology as potentially misleading.
Common issues raised included: presenting investment-level gross IRR alongside fund-level net IRR without explanation, treating subscription line financing differently in gross vs. net IRR, and inconsistently switching methodology across decks, funds, or periods.
To help firms void these pitfalls, speakers highlighted several expectations:
· Clearly identify whether IRR is calculated at the investment level or fund level.
· Use the same level of calculation for both gross and net IRR unless a clear, disclosed rationale exists.
· Apply subscription line impacts consistently across both gross and net.
· Label fund-level gross IRR clearly, if used(including gross returns is optional).
· Ensure net IRR reflects all fees, expenses, and carried interest.
· Disclose any intentional methodological differences clearly and prominently.
· Document methodology choices in policies and apply them consistently across funds.
This remains one of the most frequently cited issues in SEC exam findings for private fund advisers. In short: the SEC does not mandate a specific methodology, but it does expect consistent, well-supported approaches that avoid misleading impressions.
Evolving Expectations in Private Fund Client Reporting
Although no new regulatory requirements were announced, presenters made it clear that limited partners expect more transparency than ever before. The session included an overview of the updated ILPA reporting template along with additional information related to its implementation. Themes included:
· Clearer disclosure of fees and expenses,
· Standardized IRR and MOIC reporting,
· More detail around subscription line usage,
· Attribution and dispersion that are easy to interpret, and
· Alignment with ILPA reporting practices.
These are not formal requirements, but it’s clear the industry is moving toward more standardized and transparent reporting.
Practical Insights from SEC Exams—Including How Firms Should Approach Deficiency Letters
A recurring theme across the SEC exam sessions was the need for stronger alignment between what firms say in their policies and what they do in practice. Trends included:
· More detailed reviews of fee and expense calculations, especially for private funds,
· Larger sample requests for Marketing Rule materials,
· Increased emphasis on substantiation of all claims, and
· Close comparison of written procedures to actual workflows.
A particularly helpful part of the discussion focused on how firms should approach responding to SEC deficiency letters—something many advisers encounter at some point.
Christopher Mulligan, Partner at Weil, Gotshal & Manges LLP, offered a framework that resonated with many attendees. He explained that while the deficiency letter is addressed to the firm by the exam staff, the exam staff is not the primary audience when drafting the response.
The correct priority order is:
1. The SEC Enforcement Division
Enforcement should be able to read your response and quickly understand that: you fully grasp the issue, you have corrected or are correcting it, and nothing in the finding merits escalation.
Your first objective is to eliminate any concern that the issue rises to an enforcement matter.
2. Prospective Clients
Many allocators now request historical deficiency letters and responses during due diligence. The way the response is written—its tone, clarity, and thoroughness—can meaningfully influence how a firm is perceived.
A well-written response shows strong controls and a culture that takes compliance seriously.
3. The SEC Exam Staff
Although examiners issued the letter, they are the third audience. Their primary interest is acknowledgment and a clear explanation of the remediation steps.
Mulligan emphasized that firms often default to writing the response as if exam staff were the only audience. Reframing the response to keep the first two audiences in mind—enforcement and prospective clients—helps ensure the tone, clarity, and level of detail are appropriate and reduces both regulatory and reputational risk.
Final Thoughts
With no changes to the GIPS standards introduced this year, the 2025 conference in Phoenix served as a reminder that the real challenges involve consistency, documentation, and communication. OCIO providers in particular should be preparing for the upcoming effective date, and private fund managers continue to face rising expectations around transparent, well-supported performance reporting.
Across all sessions, a common theme emerged: clear methodology and strong internal processes are becoming just as important as the performance results themselves.
This is exactly where Longs Peak focuses its work. Our team specializes in helping firms document and implement practical, well-controlled investment performance frameworks—from IRR methodologies and composite construction to Marketing Rule compliance, fee and expense controls, and preparing for GIPS standards verification. We take the technical complexity and turn it into clear, operational processes that withstand both client due diligence and regulatory scrutiny.
If you’d like to discuss how we can help strengthen your performance reporting or compliance program, we’d be happy to talk. Contact us.
Recommended Post

Key Takeaways from the 30th Annual GIPS® Standards Conference in Philadelphia
CFA Institute hosted the 30th Annual Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) Conference on November 10 and 11, 2026 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Thirty years in, the conference still does what it does best, bringing the performance community together to work through the issues that land on our desks. It was good to reconnect with familiar faces and to see plenty of first timers in the room.
The theme was shaping what is next in investment performance, and one topic ran through nearly every session: artificial intelligence. AI was not limited to the sessions dedicated to it. It came up in verification, in the SEC discussion, in the GIPS Standards update, and across the questions attendees submitted all week. Other themes included SEC examination priorities, proposed guidance on trade errors, performance-based fee calculations, the retailization of private markets, and the asset owner view of GIPS compliance. Here are the takeaways worth passing along.
AI Took Center Stage
The audience polls reflected both enthusiasm for AI and caution about its use. Seventy-five percent of attendees expect AI and automation to have the greatest impact on verification over the next five years. At the same time, 84% were least comfortable fully delegating final approval of client communications to AI. Roughly 80% also believe the GIPS standards need little adjustment in response to AI, with only minor tweaks necessary.
CFA Institute's framing seemed reassuring for firms already experimenting. AI is treated as one more tool in the performance process, much like an accounting or performance system. Using it does not, by itself, jeopardize a firm's GIPS compliance. What matters is how firms oversee its use. CFA Institute is researching model bias and ethics to decide whether changes to the standards are needed.
The practical sessions showed how much is already possible, from building efficient frontier analysis and tracking error decomposition to drafting attribution commentary with an AI agent in a fraction of the usual time. The consistent message from presenters was that the human must be in the loop. One speaker summed it upwell: delegate tasks, but do not delegate responsibility. Some errors are harder to spot than an obvious hallucination. For example, where the numbers are right, but the interpretation is wrong. The expectation is a clear chain of evidence behind any result, with a qualified person reviewing it before it goes out.
That theme carried into record keeping. When AI contributes to a calculation, a disclosure, or a GIPS Report, firms should retain enough information to support and recreate the result, as verifiers or regulators may ask for it. In practice that means documenting how AI is used in your policies and procedures, keeping version control over prompts, and retaining the underlying data. The accountability does not transfer to the software.
CFA Institute is gathering industry input through its AI and performance survey. Responses will help inform any future updates to the GIPS standards. If you work in performance, we encourage you to participate. Keep an eye out for the survey from CFA Institute as it has currently only been made available on the conference app, but we hope they will send it out soon.
The GIPS Standards Update: What Is New and What Is Coming
As of October31, 2026, 1,647 organizations across 51 markets claim compliance with the GIPS standards, including 25 of the top 25 and 85 of the top 100 global firms. Adoption remains strongest in the US, UK, Canada, Switzerland, and South Africa, with Saudi Arabia now in the top ten.
The headline project is a proposed Guidance Statement on Trade Errors, out for comment through December 15, 2026. Trade errors happen at every firm, and the proposal addresses how to handle them in portfolios and composites alongside a firm's error correction policy. The key points in the proposed new guidance are that a trade error policy would be optional, much like a significant cash flow policy, while error correction stays mandatory for compliant firms. The guidance would add a narrow new reason a firm may remove a portfolio from a composite. Presenters were clear that this is not a way to drop a poor performer by calling it an error, and that firms would need consistent materiality thresholds. If you have opinions you would like to share about this guidance before it is finalized, please submit your comment letters to gipsstandards@cfainstitute.orgby 15 December.
CFA Institute also released a Guide for Return Attribution Reporting and the third edition of its paper Reconciling the GIPS Standards and the SEC Marketing Rule. Further out, a GIPS 2030consultation paper is taking shape, with net-of-fee presentation, model portfolios, after-tax reporting, and AI all on the list. One idea under consideration would let firms present the net return relevant to a prospect, not only the most conservative net return, which would help align the GIPS standards with the SEC Marketing Rule.
SEC Marketing Rule and the Current State of Exams
Mark Dowdell of the SEC Division of Examinations gave another candid session. The 2027 exam program is squarely retail focused, with attention on fiduciary duties, conflicts of interest, liquidity, complex products, and private credit valuation, along with cybersecurity and AI.
On the Marketing Rule, recent staff guidance has eased two pain points. Firms now have a safe harbor to show investment characteristics and extracted performance on a gross basis, as long as the related composite or total-portfolio gross and net returns appear with equal prominence over the same period and the gross figures are clearly labeled. Firms also have more flexibility to present net performance using actual fees even when those are lower than the anticipated fee, with appropriate disclosure. Also, it was clarified that returns that comply with the SEC Marketing Rule, but do not meet the requirements of the GIPS standards, may be presented as supplemental information for a GIPS compliant firm.
Examination findings continue to highlight familiar weaknesses. Firms are still cited for policies that were never updated for the Marketing Rule and for annual reviews that lack real testing. Hypothetical and predecessor performance remain trouble spots, and examiners continue to check incentive fee calculations against the governing documents. On AI, the message was straightforward: if you use it to help review or sign off on performance, have policies around it, human oversight, and supporting documentation, because the staff will ask how the tools are used. The SEC also cited firms that exaggerate their use of AI.
Performance-Based Fees: Small Details, Significant Implications
A session on performance-based fees drove home a single point: small differences in contractual language can materially change what a general partner earns. Compounding frequency, catch-up provisions, high-water marks, and the choice between European and American style waterfalls can each swing the result. Whether carried interest is structured as a fee or an allocation of profit can also change its tax implications.
The session emphasized the need for shared understanding of the calculation. Lawyers draft the terms, administrators calculate the fees, and auditors verify the result. The intent, the language, and the calculation all have to agree. Many attendees asked whether any system can handle bespoke fee calculations well or if the work still ends up in Excel. The vast majority still seem to be using Excel for these calculations although there is some shift to software solutions. A pending SEC proposal could extend the use of incentive fees to a broader set of public funds, potentially bringing these challenges to more of the industry.
Private Markets and Retailization
As private markets expand into wealth and retirement channels, the recurring message was that access is only part of the equation. As one panelist put it, private markets are a decision inside plan design, not a decision instead of it.
The harder issue is valuation. In semi-liquid and evergreen vehicles, the net asset value is not just a reporting mark, it is the price at which investors subscribe and redeem. This makes valuation accuracy more important than ever. Appraisal-based values can smooth volatility and delay the recognition of losses, and every private market metric ultimately rests on an estimate of what is still held. The guidance for practitioners was to clearly separate realized cash returns from the manager’s unrealized estimates, disclose smoothing and benchmark limits, and tailor the disclosure to the investor. It was also noted that even when AI supports a valuation model, the valuer remains accountable for the result.
Asset Owner Perspectives
A panel of GIPS compliant asset owners, including the Public Investment Fund of Saudi Arabia, MassPRIM, and the Pennsylvania Treasury, shared why they pursued compliance when no client required it. In each case the decision came from the top and was about institutional excellence and the confidence that independently verified numbers give boards, oversight bodies, and the external managers they hire. One panelist described compliance by osmosis: once the organization commits, the whole team pays closer attention to the inputs that drive performance, and issues get caught before they grow.
A poll showed that most asset owner RFPs now ask whether managers are GIPS compliant, and a growing number ask across all asset classes. This pulls compliance into less transparent parts of the market such as private assets. The panelists were candid about shared challenges, including lagged private market valuations, but were encouraging about the path forward for more asset owners to claim compliance. They noted that compliance is achievable even with a small team when the right custodian, verifier, and consultant are in place.
This is one of the threads we watched most closely. Asset owner adoption raises the bar for everyone, because an asset owner that has done the work expects the same discipline, ethics, and full disclosure from the managers it hires. Helping asset owners and the managers they evaluate meet that standard is a core part of our work, and we expect this community to keep driving demand for GIPS compliance across asset classes.
Final Thoughts
For all the focus on technology, the message from Philadelphia was that the fundamentals have not changed. AI can improve the speed and quality of performance work, but trustworthy reporting still depends on transparency, consistency, documentation, and human accountability. The firms that come out ahead will treat AI as leverage for their expertise rather than a replacement for it, and keep their policies, records, and review processes a step ahead of the tools.
At Longs Peak, we help firms and asset owners put these principles into practice. We helpbuild practical, well-controlled performance and GIPS compliant processes, from composite construction, performance reporting, and Marketing Rule presentations to preparation for verification. Increasingly, it also includes helping clientsdocument and oversee AI use within those processes. If you would like to talk through how any of these developments affect your organization, please contact us.

If AI does much of the performance work that taught us,what will teach the next generation of performance experts?
I recently sat in on a webinar with Hope Morrissey of BigPi on building AI tools inside a firm. It was practical and timely: at Longs Peak, we are building out our own workbench, and much of the conversation mapped onto choices we are making right now.
But the question I asked at the end wasn't about tooling. It was about people.
Most of us learned this profession by doing grunt work. We linked monthly returns by hand in Excel. We built and rebuilt composites line by line. We chased a 3 bp difference for an afternoon and found a fee posted to the wrong month. We made mistakes, and someone more experienced caught them and explained why.
That work is going away, and maybe it should. AI and automation increasingly handle reconciliation, first-pass review and draft disclosures faster than any analyst. What's left, and what matters most, is judgment and expertise.
Which raises the uncomfortable part: if the work that built today's experts disappears, how do we build tomorrow's?
The grunt work was never really about the math
Looking back, the spreadsheets weren't the lesson. They were the delivery mechanism for three things that nobody taught us directly.
- A feel for what normal looks like. After linking monthly returns for a few months or running VLOOKUPs to map the right data to the right composite, you get to know what a normal month looks like and, perhaps more importantly, when one looks off.
- A map of where things break. Every error made by hand taught us where errors live: the cash flow cutoff, the fee accrual, the stale price, or the account that should have left the composite two months ago.
- Ownership of the number. When you built it yourself, you could defend it. You knew every assumption inside it.
That is the raw material of judgment. AI doesn't remove the need for it. It removes the accidental way we used to acquire it. So, the answer isn't to preserve busywork for its own sake. It's to identify what the grunt work was teaching and teach it on purpose.
Judgment is the new edge
Shortly after the webinar, I came across a LinkedIn post built on comments NVIDIA CEO Jensen Huang made on the podcast A Bit Personal. Huang pushed back on the usual definition of smart: "somebody who's intelligent, solves [technical] problems." His view: "I find that's a commodity." The people he values are technically astute but can also "infer the unspoken" and "see around corners."
That lands hard in performance measurement. For two decades our credibility rested on getting the math right: time-weighted returns, composite construction, dispersion, three-year standard deviation. Systems already do most of that. AI is now taking the rest.
What remains is the judgment call, the “unknowables.” Is this account still discretionary? Does this cash flow policy make sense for how the strategy is actually marketed? Is this benchmark still the right comparison after the strategy drifted (or the benchmark got too concentrated)?
Those questions don't have a formula and often require interpretation rather than automation. They have experience behind them. And that brings us back to the training problem.
Rebuilding the apprenticeship on purpose
Historically, nobody had to think very hard about how someone learned the job. You hired smart people, gave them the work, and the work did the teaching. Judgment showed up eventually, usually starting somewhere around the end of the first year.
That approach falls apart once the work itself is automated. If we want people who can make good calls, we have to create the experiences that used to happen by accident. I don’t think we have this fully figured out, but these are the five things I keep coming back to.
1. Do it by hand once, then let the machine do it
I still think every new analyst should calculate both time-weighted and money-weighted returns by hand, link a quarter of monthly returns, and put together a small composite from scratch, at least once. Nobody is going to do it that way in production. The point is that it's very hard to supervise a process you've never done yourself. If you don't know where a cashflow belongs in the formula, you won't notice when something is in the wrong place.
Once they've done it, have them run the same data through your automation tools and compare. Sometimes the results match. If they don't, working out why (a different day-weighting convention, a fee treated differently, a cash flow on the wrong date) teaches more about how th calculation really works than any training deck I've seen.
2. Make the reviewer the new entry-level job
For most performance teams, the junior job was to produce the number and someone more senior checked it. Now the machine increasingly produces the number, so the junior job becomes checking it. That's a harder place to start, because we're asking people to review work they may not have spent years doing themselves.
One way to close that gap is to build exercises out of past results. Take AI-generated output and plant real errors (built from anonymized or synthetic examples) seen over the years: a mispriced security, a trade booked a day late, a fee posted to the wrong month, an account that should have left the composite and didn't. Ask newer team members to find them before a senior reviewer does. They may not catch everything at first, and that's fine. Talking through what they missed is where the pattern recognition starts to form, much the way it formed when those mistakes were made by doing the work by hand.
3. Write down the instinct before you investigate
Experienced performance professionals can usually tell something is off before they can explain why. Dispersion that jumps dramatically in a calm quarter. An account that is consistently a composite outlier. A composite return that beats every account in it, by a lot. That instinct is valuable, but it isn't always right. Sometimes it's just bias, and the number is actually fine.
A simple habit helps. When something looks wrong, have the analyst write down what they think is going on before they start digging. Once they've found the answer, have them go back and note whether their first read held up. After a few months they should have a real record of where their instincts are reliable and where they aren't. When those notes are tracked and talked through as part of training, senior team members can see how someone reasons, not just whether they got the right answer.
4. Teach people to hear what isn't in the file
Much of our value sits in the gap between the data and what's happening at the firm. An account quietly drops out of a composite and nobody mentions why. Marketing starts promoting a new strategy before anyone has asked whether it needs its own composite. A portfolio manager mentions "a bit of a style tilt" in passing on a call. None of that is in the file, and AI can only work from the context we provide. If no one recognize what matters and brings it to the table, the tool will never know it was there.
That kind of listening is not new, but it is hard to teach in a classroom. The best way I know is to bring junior team members into the rooms where it happens, early, even if they don't say a word. On an in-house performance team, that might be the monthly attribution review with the portfolio managers, the product committee when a new strategy is on the table, or the kickoff call with your verifier. On our side as consultants, it's client calls and verification kickoffs. In-house teams actually have an advantage here because they sit down the hall from PMs, operations and compliance, and an informal conversation is often where changes show up. Encourage juniors to participate in those conversations instead of working only from the data feed.
Either way, debrief afterward. Ask what they heard that wasn't in the data, and what they would follow up on. The first few answers maybe thin, so share what you heard. Over time they'll pick up on things they used to overlook. That's probably one of the clearest signs that someone is developing real judgment.
5. Turn your own history into the curriculum
Our best training material is our own history of judgment calls. Build a library of real cases (anonymized of course): the facts, what was decided, why, and what you'd do differently now. Include the ones you got wrong.
Run "what could go wrong" exercises together to pass judgment along. Before a verification, exam, or new factsheet goes out, get the team together and ask: "It's six months from now and this went badly. What happened?" Have everyone write their answers down before anyone shares. Newer staff hear what experienced people worry about and why: an undocumented policy change, hypothetical performance shown without the required policies, a net-of-fee calculation that doesn't tie to the fee schedule. That's knowledge that usually takes years to pick up by accident.
What this asks of leaders
This isn't only a training problem. It's a leadership choice about where the time AI saves actually goes.
- Reinvest the hours. If automation saves a senior reviewer ten hours a month, some of those hours belong to teaching. Otherwise, efficiency quietly eats the pipeline of future experts.
- Hire for judgment. Give candidates a messy composite file and ask what worries them, rather than screening on credentials alone.
- Build tools that explain, not just answer. As we build our workbench at Longs Peak, one question I keep asking is whether our tools show its reasoning. A tool that explains why it flagged an account teaches. A tool that just flags it doesn't.
- Measure what matters. Performance teams measure investment results for a living, yet rarely measure their own judgment. Whether you sit inside an investment firm or advise one, track the issues your team caught before the verifier, auditor, compliance or a regulator did, and who caught them. Over time, that tells you more about how your people are developing than how quickly the reports go out.
The experts of the future won't learn the way we did
That's not a loss if we're deliberate about it. The firms that get this right will use AI to move people faster from producing numbers to questioning them, and they'll treat that shift as a training design problem, not a happy accident.
I don't think anyone has fully solved this yet. We’re trying to be intentional about our future pipeline. I'd like to hear how other performance teams are approaching it. What are you doing to build judgment in people who may never link a return by hand?
And as always, reach out if you want help rethinking how your team builds judgment in performance measurement at hello@longspeakadvisory.com.
Sources
- Jensen Huang quotes as reported by Upworthy (Feb 3, 2026), from his appearance on A Bit Personal with Jodi Shelton.

Every so often we hear it: "Oh, you're one of the performance software tools."
It's an understandable assumption. We work in the same world as the software providers: composites, Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®), performance data, and the systems that produce all of it. From the outside, it can look like we're all selling the same thing.
We aren't. And if you're deciding how to support your performance and GIPS compliance work, the difference is worth understanding.
The short version: Longs Peak is a team of people who do the work with you, or for you. We're not a platform you log into. Behind the scenes, our tools help our team deliver faster, more consistent service. But no number leaves our hands without a real performance expert standing behind it.
Software Gives You a Capability. Someone Still Has to Run It.
A software provider hands you a tool. A good one can be powerful, and those systems offer a ton of capabilities. But once the tool is installed, the work to run it lands on your desk.
Someone on your team still has to load the data, set up and maintain the composites, review the results, chase down the account that looks off, and know the GIPS standards well enough to make the judgment calls. Software can calculate a return. It can't decide whether a new account belongs in a composite, explain why a number moved, or figure out what to do when a custodian changes its data feed.
What We Actually Do
At Longs Peak, we get our hands dirty, so you don't have to. In practice, that means:
- We manage your composites. Membership decisions, inclusion and exclusion, periodic updates, and the returns that come out the other end. We work alongside members of your team to get those questions answered and make the updates for you. The work gets done by a person who does it every day.
- We act as your GIPS expert. When a new strategy launches, a policy needs revisiting, or a gray area comes up, you have someone who knows the standards and has seen the situation before.
- We dig into your data. We look for outliers, accounts that are breaking composite rules, and other anomalies, before they end up in your reported performance and get caught in verification. Not only do we help identify potential issues, but we work with your team to help create the paper trail to provide an explanation if questioned by a verifier.
- We help with system issues. When your system isn't producing what you need, we get inside it and help work out why.
- We design the output. Once the data work is done, we turn it into beautifully designed, client-ready factsheets and reporting. And we understand this information from a performance, compliance, and design perspective.
- We help you communicate what matters most. For your prospects or a board of directors: which statistics support your story, and which just add noise? Those are communication choices, and we help you make them.
None of this is advice delivered from a distance. We maywork with you as a remote team, but we're not remotely hands-off. We work insideyour data, your systems, and your deadlines, the same way a colleague down thehall would. And when something needs fixing, we roll up our sleeves and fix it,so it’s off your plate and your to-do list.
Ways to Work With Us
Every firm is set up differently, so we don't force a single model.
- Fully outsourced. We run composite management on your behalf, start to finish. For firms without a dedicated performance team, this is often the cleanest answer.
- Part of your team. We work alongside your people, taking on the pieces that are heavy, specialized, or just hard to staff. To your colleagues, we're simply part of the performance team.
- Your GIPS expert on call. Your team runs the day-to-day, and we're there for the questions, reviews, and judgment calls that need someone who has seen it all before.
- Your marketing team. Your data is done and ready to be put to work. We turn it into polished factsheets and reporting for prospects, consultants, and boards, and help you decide which parts of your story deserve the spotlight.
Many clients start in one place and shift as their needs change. That flexibility allows us to grow alongside you and offer as much or little support as you need.
Why This Matters
Most firms don't struggle with GIPS compliance because they misunderstand a requirement. They struggle because the knowledge lives in one person's head, the team is stretched thin, or a system issue has been quietly sitting in the queue for months.
Software doesn't fix any of those problems. People do. Having an experienced team involved reduces key-person risk, frees your own staff for higher-value work, and means fewer surprises when verification or a regulatory review comes around.
A Question Worth Asking
If the person who runs your performance work were out for a month, who would pick it up? And if the honest answer is "we'd figure it out" or you simply don’t have an answer, it may be time to think about who else should be in the room.
We're happy to talk through where you are today and what kind of support would actually help. No software demo required. Email us at hello@longspeakadvisory.com.
GIPS® is a registered trademark owned by CFA Institute. CFA Institute does not endorse or promote this organization, nor does it warrant the accuracy or quality of the content contained herein.



