What is Up-Market & Down-Market Capture Ratio?

Jocelyn Gilligan
CFA, CIPM - Partner
December 21, 2021
15 min
What is Up-Market & Down-Market Capture Ratio?

What do Capture Ratios Explain?

Capture ratios help investors assess how a strategy holds up during different market conditions. They can be used to demonstrate how a strategy performs across different cycles of the market by quantifying how much of the market performance your strategy “captures” on the way up or on the way down.

What is the Up-Market Capture Ratio?

The Up-Market Capture Ratio evaluates a strategy's performance in up-markets. It measures how well a manager performed relative to its benchmark during rising market conditions. The ratio is calculated by dividing the average strategy returns by the average returns of the benchmark, but only including periods where the benchmark returns were positive.

Up-Market Capture Formula

How to interpret the Up-Market Capture Ratio

It is best to compare the results of both Up-Market and Down-Market Capture to 100. For Up-Market Capture, it is ideal to have a result greater than 100 because this signifies that the strategy outperformed the benchmark while the market is rising. For example, if the Up-Market Capture is 115, this shows that the strategy outperformed the benchmark by 15% during the period. This is a helpful indicator for managers that want to demonstrate that their strategy will beat the index during rising market conditions.

However, because this measure focuses on the upside, it will not give you a full picture of the strategy’s performance. A defensive strategy, focused on downside protection, may have a low up-market capture, but still be outperforming because of its low market capture on the downside. It is therefore most common to present this measure in conjunction with the Down-Market Capture Ratio, to provide a more complete picture of overall performance.

What is the Down-Market Capture Ratio?

The Down-Market Capture Ratio assesses a strategy's performance in down-markets and measures how well a manager performed relative to the index while the market is falling. Similar to Up-Market Capture, it is calculated by dividing the average strategy returns by the average returns of the benchmark, but only including periods where the benchmark returns were negative.

Down-Market Capture Formula

How to interpret the Down-Market Capture Ratio

For the Down-Market Capture Ratio, it is ideal to have a result less than 100 because this signifies that the strategy outperformed the benchmark while the market is falling. For example, if the Down-Market Capture is 90, this shows that, on average, the strategy declined only 90% as much as the benchmark did during down periods. This is a helpful indicator for managers that want to demonstrate that their strategy outperforms during market decline. Again, because this measure focuses only on the downside, it will not provide a full picture of the strategy’s performance and should be presented together with the Up-Market Capture Ratio to provide a more complete picture.

What is Total Capture Ratio?

Total Capture Ratio measures the asymmetry of returns, quantifying overall performance across different phases of the market. Total Capture Ratio is calculated by dividing the Up-Market Capture Ratio by the Down-Market Capture Ratio.

Total Capture Ratio Formula

Total capture ratio formula

How to interpret Total Capture Ratio

A Capture Ratio greater than one (1) indicates that the strategy outperformed the benchmark overall. For example, if the Down-Market Capture is 115, but Up-Market Capture is 130, this gives you a Total Capture Ratio of 1.13, indicating that the performance in rising markets offsets the performance during market slump. The same is true for strategies whose primary objective is to protect on the downside. Even when up-market capture is low or breaks even, if the strategy performs well in down markets, it can still outperform the market overall. For example, an up-market capture of 80 and down-market capture of 60 results in total capture of 1.33.

Why are Capture Ratios Important?

Capture ratios are used to assess whether a strategy is performing according to its investment objective. If the goal of the strategy is to outperform its benchmark, Capture ratios will help demonstrate how the strategy outperformed – whether on the up-side, down-side or overall.

Questions?

If you have questions our would like help calculating risk statistics for your strategy, contact us. Or check out other investment performance statistics we've written about, including the Sharpe Ratio, Information Ratio, and others.

Recommended Post

View All Articles
ColoradoBiz Names Longs Peak’s Jocelyn Gilligan, CFA, CIPM as a GenZYZ Top Young Professional
Longs Peak is pleased to announce that Partner and Co-Founder, Jocelyn Gilligan has been named a GenXYZ Top Young Professional by ColoradoBiz Magazine. As ColoradoBiz states, “They’re uncommon achievers, whether as entrepreneurs, CEOs, nonprofit leaders, visionaries critical to their companies’ success or, in some cases, all of those roles. This year’s Top 25 Young Professionals figure to continue making a difference professionally and in their communities for years to come.”
March 14, 2023
15 min

Longs Peak is pleased to announce that Partner and Co-Founder, Jocelyn Gilligan has been named a GenXYZ Top Young Professional by ColoradoBiz Magazine.

As ColoradoBiz states, “They’re uncommon achievers, whether as entrepreneurs, CEOs, nonprofit leaders, visionaries critical to their companies’ success or, in some cases, all of those roles. This year’s Top 25 Young Professionals figure to continue making a difference professionally and in their communities for years to come.”

Jocelyn grew up in Boulder, CO and graduated from the University of Colorado. She started her career at Ernst & Young in New York City where she worked on their Financial Services Transfer Pricing Team. She transferred with EY to their office in Shanghai and then eventually to Hong Kong. Jocelyn left EY as a Manager and relocated back to Colorado where she and her husband started a family. Soon thereafter, Jocelyn and Sean founded Longs Peak out of a small one-car garage in their home in Longmont, CO. Now running a thriving team of 14, Jocelyn has weathered the ups and downs of entrepreneurship. She credits a lot of their success to their amazing team and the community of entrepreneurs they live near and network with (Longs Peak is an active member of EO (Entrepreneurs Organization)).

Jocelyn is a voting member of the PTO at her children’s school and a member of Women in Investment Performance Measurement, a group recently founded to support women in the investment performance industry.

Please join us in celebrating this year’s ColoradoBiz Top Young Professionals nominees. You can view the complete list of nominees here

About ColoradoBiz’s Top 25 Young Professionals

The 13th annual Gen XYZ awards is open to those under 40 who live and work in Colorado — numbered in the hundreds, making for difficult decisions and conversations among judges, as always. Applications were judged by our editorial board based on career achievement, community engagement and their stories of how they got to where they are now.

About Longs Peak

Longs Peak is a purpose and values-driven company. It is our mission to make investment performance information more transparent and reliable—empowering investors to make better, more informed investment decisions.

At the onset, we were looking to help smaller investment managers by giving them access to professional performance experts and tools typically only available to very large firms. We know that our work enables emerging managers to compete with the big guys and helps facilitate their growth. We strive to be our clients’ most valued outsource partner and to be known for our exceptional client service. We know that providing exceptional client service means that we must first create a culture that lives by the ideals we are trying to create for our clients. A place where incredibly talented individuals are empowered to put their best work into the hands of clients that truly value what we do. As a firm, we recognize that our greatest asset is people – both those we work with and those we work for. We continue to evolve into something that represents the needs of both of these groups and hope someday a GIPS Report is provided to every prospective investor in the world.

SEC Clarifies Marketing Rule: Gross-of-Fee Returns Allowed Under Certain Conditions
The investment management industry has spent significant time grappling with the SEC’s Marketing Rule and the question of whether gross-of-fee returns can be presented without corresponding net-of-fee returns in certain cases. Many firms have invested resources in trying to allocate fees to individual securities and sectors in an effort to comply. However, the SEC has now issued two FAQs (March 19, 2025) that provide much appreciated clarity on extracted performance and portfolio characteristics. The key takeaway? It is possible to present gross-of-fee returns without net-of-fee returns—if certain conditions are met.
March 27, 2025
15 min

The investment management industry has spent significant time grappling with the SEC’s Marketing Rule and the question of whether gross-of-fee returns can be presented without corresponding net-of-fee returns in certain cases. Many firms have invested resources in trying to allocate fees to individual securities and sectors in an effort to comply. However, the SEC has now issued two FAQs (March 19, 2025) that provide much appreciated clarity on extracted performance and portfolio characteristics. The key takeaway? It is possible to present gross-of-fee returns without net-of-fee returns—if certain conditions are met.

Extracted Performance: Gross Returns Can Stand Alone Under Specific Criteria

Investment advisers often present the performance of a single investment or a subset of a portfolio (“extracted performance”) in marketing materials. Historically, the SEC required both gross and net performance to be shown for such extracts. The new guidance provides a pathway for firms to display only gross-of-fee extracted performance, provided the following conditions are met:

  1. The extracted performance must be clearly identified as gross performance.
  2. The advertisement must also present the total portfolio’s gross and net performance in a manner consistent with SEC requirements.
  3. The total portfolio’s performance must be given at least equal prominence to, and facilitate comparison with, the extracted performance.
  4. The total portfolio’s performance must be calculated over a period that includes the entire period of the extracted performance.

If these conditions are satisfied, the SEC staff has indicated they will not recommend enforcement action, even if the extracted performance is presented without corresponding net returns. This is a notable shift, as it allows firms to avoid the complex and often impractical task of allocating fees at the investment or sector level.

Portfolio and Investment Characteristics: Net-of-Fee Not Always Required

Another common industry question has been whether certain portfolio or investment characteristics—such as yield, volatility, Sharpe ratio, sector returns, or attribution analysis—constitute “performance” under the marketing rule, and if so, whether they must be presented net of fees.

The SEC’s latest guidance acknowledges that calculating these characteristics net of fees can be difficult and, in some cases, may lead to misleading results. As a result, the staff has confirmed that firms may present gross characteristics alone, without net characteristics, if they meet the following criteria:

  1. The characteristic must be clearly identified as calculated without the deduction of fees and expenses.
  2. The advertisement must also present the total portfolio’s gross and net performance in a manner consistent with SEC requirements.
  3. The total portfolio’s performance must be given at least equal prominence to, and facilitate comparison with, the gross characteristic.
  4. The total portfolio’s performance must be calculated over a period that includes the entire period of the characteristic being presented.

As with extracted performance, these conditions help ensure that the presentation is not misleading, reducing the risk of enforcement action.

Bottom Line: A Practical Path Forward

This updated SEC guidance provides much-needed flexibility for investment managers, allowing for the presentation of gross-of-fee returns in a compliant manner. Firms that clearly disclose their approach and follow the specified conditions can reduce compliance burdens while still meeting investor protection standards. While this does not eliminate all complexities of the Marketing Rule, it does offer a practical solution that allows for more straightforward and meaningful performance reporting.

For firms navigating these changes, ensuring clear disclosures and maintaining compliance with the general prohibitions of the rule remains critical. Those who align their advertising materials with these guidelines can now confidently use gross-of-fee performance in a way that is both transparent and in compliance with regulatory requirements.

Questions?

If you have questions about calculating or presenting investment performance in a manner that complies with regulatory requirements or industry best practices, we would love to talk to you. Please feel free to email us at hello@longspeakadvisory.com.

New GIPS Standards Guidance for OCIOs: What You Need to Know
The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) have released a new Guidance Statement for OCIO Portfolios, bringing greater transparency and consistency to the way Outsourced Chief Investment Officers (OCIOs) report performance. This update is a significant milestone for firms managing OCIO Portfolios and asset owners looking to evaluate their OCIO providers.
February 3, 2025
15 min

The Global Investment Performance Standards (GIPS®) have released a new Guidance Statement for OCIO Portfolios, bringing greater transparency and consistency to the way Outsourced Chief Investment Officers (OCIOs) report performance. This update is a significant milestone for firms managing OCIO Portfolios and asset owners looking to evaluate their OCIO providers.

What is an OCIO?

An Outsourced Chief Investment Officer (OCIO) is a third-party fiduciary that provides both strategic investment advice and investment management services to institutional investors such as pension funds, endowments, and foundations. Instead of building an in-house investment team, asset owners delegate investment decisions to an OCIO, which handles everything from strategic planning to portfolio management.

Who Does the New Guidance Apply To?

The Guidance Statement for OCIO Portfolios applies when a firm provides both:

  1. Strategic investment advice, including developing or assessing an asset owner’s strategic asset allocation and investment policy statement.
  2. Investment management services, such as portfolio construction, fund and manager selection, and ongoing management.

This ensures that firms managing OCIO Portfolios follow standardized performance reporting, making it easier for prospective clients to compare OCIO providers.

Who is Exempt from the OCIO Guidance?

The guidance does not apply in the following scenarios:

  • Investment management without strategic advice – If a firm only manages investments without advising on asset allocation or investment policy.
  • Strategic advice without investment management – If a firm provides recommendations but does not manage the portfolio.
  • Partial OCIO portfolios – If a firm only manages a portion of a portfolio, rather than the full OCIO mandate.
  • Retail client portfolios – The guidance is specific to institutional OCIO Portfolios and does not apply to retail investors including larger wealth management portfolios.

Key Change: Required OCIO Composites

Previously, OCIO firms had flexibility in defining their performance composites. Now, the GIPS Standards introduce Required OCIO Composites, which categorize portfolios based on strategic asset allocation.

Types of Required OCIO Composites

  1. Liability-Focused Composites – Designed for portfolios aiming to meet specific liability streams, such as corporate pensions.
  2. Total Return Composites – Focused on capital appreciation, commonly used by endowments and foundations.

Firms must classify OCIO Portfolios based on their strategic allocation, not short-term tactical shifts. This standardization enhances comparability across OCIO providers. The specific allocation ranges for the required composites are as follows:

Required OCIO Composites for OCIO Portfolios

Required OCIO Composites
Source: Guidance Statement for OCIO Portfolios

Performance Calculation & Reporting

To ensure transparency, firms must follow specific rules for return calculations and fee disclosures:

  • Time-weighted returns (TWR) are required, even for portfolios with private equity or real estate holdings.
  • Both gross and net-of-fee returns must be presented to clarify the true cost of OCIO management.
  • Fee schedule disclosures must include all investment management fees, including fees from proprietary funds and third-party placements.

Enhanced Transparency in GIPS Reports

The new guidance also requires OCIO firms to disclose additional portfolio details, such as:

  • Annual asset allocation breakdowns (e.g., growth vs. liability-hedging assets).
  • Private market investment and hedge fund exposures.
  • Portfolio characteristics, such as funding ratios and duration for liability-focused portfolios.

By providing these details, OCIO firms enable prospective clients to make better-informed decisions when selecting an investment partner.

When Do These Changes Take Effect?

The Guidance Statement for OCIO Portfolios is effective December 31, 2025. From this date forward, GIPS Reports for Required OCIO Composites must follow the new standards. However, firms are encouraged to adopt the guidance earlier to improve transparency and reporting consistency.

Why This Matters

With OCIO services growing in popularity, this new guidance ensures that firms adhere to best practices in performance reporting. By establishing clear rules for composite classification, return calculation, and fee disclosure, the guidance empowers asset owners to compare OCIO providers with confidence.

As the December 31, 2025 deadline approaches, OCIO firms should begin aligning their reporting practices with this new guidance to stay ahead of the curve.

Don’t miss CFA Institute’s webinar scheduled for this Thursday February 6, 2025 to hear more on this guidance statement.

Questions?

If you have questions about the Guidance Statement for OCIO Portfolios or the Standards in general, we would love to talk to you. Longs Peak’s professionals have extensive experience helping firms become GIPS compliant as well as helping firms maintain their compliance with the GIPS Standards on an ongoing basis. Please feel free to email us at hello@longspeakadvisory.com.